Vintage vs Modern Engagement Rings: Which is Right for Her?

Whether you choose the royalty of vintage rings or the effortless charm of modern designs, we bring the best of both to you.

When you look at your unique engagement rings, we want you to see more than just a sparkling jewel or a band of gold. A hearty symbol of love or a timeless promise of shared love. The ring that graces your finger should reflect your unique story, personality, and values.

And in the quest to find the ideal piece, one of the most defining choices you'll make is whether to opt for a modern engagement ring or a vintage one.

Vintage, unique engagement rings evoke the timeless charm of eras past, whispering stories of yesteryear. On the other hand, modern styles boast bold and more effortless narratives. As we deep dive into their allure, you'll gain insights to discover that special ring—one that resonates deeply with your taste, your love story, and you.

Embracing the Past: Vintage-Inspired Designs

Vintage engagement rings offer us a timeless choice steeped in nostalgia and elegance. When we envision "vintage," we're transported to eras of bygone charm and sophistication, spanning from the early 1900s to the 1980s. Within this broad spectrum, we encounter captivating periods like retro, art deco, and Edwardian, each exuding its own unique allure.

Let's journey through history and explore the distinct designs of each era. Picture the daring spirit of the retro era in the 1940s and 1950s, with its bold and grandiose pieces reminiscent of classic Hollywood glamor. Now, immerse yourself in the geometric patterns and vibrant gemstones of the Art Deco movement during the roaring 1920s and 30s—a celebration of extravagance and sophistication mirroring the Jazz Age.

Meanwhile, the Edwardian era, spanning the early 1900s to the 1910s, was captivated by delicate, lace-like designs crafted using innovative platinum filigree techniques.

Our Best-Selling Vintage-Inspired Designs

Take a look at some of our best-sellers inspired by the royalty and grace of a bygone era.

Avery. Oval 5/8ctw. Diamond Vintage-Inspired Halo Engagement Ring in 14k White Gold

Crafted in 14-karat polished white gold, this stunning vintage-inspired design features an oval center diamond and round brilliant diamonds on the shank, adding a glamorous sparkle.

Vintage-Inspired 1/10ctw. Engagement Ring in Sterling Silver

Introducing our elegant vintage engagement ring, adorned with 1/10ctw. of brilliant-cut diamonds. This exquisite ring symbolizes your commitment and is a beautiful addition to any jewelry collection.

Bold and Contemporary: Modern Interpretations of Engagement Rings

Modern engagement rings bring a fresh vibe to bridal jewelry, featuring contemporary designs and innovative elements. They boast clean lines, minimalistic styles, and a blend of traditional and unconventional materials.

These unique engagement rings exude simplicity and elegance with sleek, geometric designs that ooze sophistication. The timeless diamond solitaire remains a popular choice, while the tension-set ring creates the illusion of the diamond floating above the finger.

Modern engagement rings also embrace creative material choices. Alongside diamonds, gemstones like sapphires, emeralds, and morganites add color and personality to designs. Metals like rose gold and mixed metals offer a contemporary twist.

Advancements in technology and craftsmanship enable customized ring designs with unprecedented precision. You can personalize every detail, ensuring your ring reflects your unique style and story like never before.

Our Best-Selling Modern Designs

Sybil. ArtCarved Diamond Oval Setting in 14k Rose Gold

Introducing Sybil, an exquisite ArtCarved® engagement ring setting designed for your oval diamond. Crafted with 32 round diamonds surrounding the center and accentuating its 14-karat rose gold straight shank. The oval center stone is sold separately.

Gemma. Diamond 1 1/4ctw. Pear Halo Engagement Ring in 14k White Gold

Start your forever journey with our latest "GEMMA" engagement ring. This exquisite pear-shaped center diamond ring boasts a halo of 10 diamonds and a diamond-accented shank, all elegantly set in 14-karat white gold. *Matching wedding band available separately.

Blending Vintage Elements With Modern Aesthetics

We are finding new ways to mix vintage charm with modern styles as more people seek vintage-style engagement rings. By combining contemporary diamond cuts with old-fashioned settings, we give classic designs a modern update. Plus, by using new materials and methods to recreate vintage looks, we make them more affordable and available to everyone.

Customization Options for Unique Style Preferences

Customization allows you to craft a ring that is truly one-of-a-kind. Explore various styles, materials, and stones to find what best matches your or your partner's tastes and preferences. With our endless options available, customization adds a personal touch to your ring, making it uniquely yours.

Here's How We Make Your Ring One-Of-A-Kind

• Our custom jewelry & engagement ring design center can help you create a one-of-a-kind treasure from conception to completion.
• With the assistance of our experts, you can design any type of fine jewelry and accessories imaginable, including one-of-a-kind rings, necklaces, and tennis or charm bracelets.
• Whether you have the exact design in mind or need help exploring options, our team will provide as much guidance as necessary.
• Start the process of bringing your design to life by uploading a photo that inspired your design, scheduling an appointment with a jewelry specialist, or exploring personalized jewelry and engravable gifts.

Factors to Consider When Exploring Unique Designs

• Determine a comfortable budget early in the process to ensure a financially sound decision. Remember that the symbolism of the ring outweighs its price tag.
• Consider customization as a way to create a truly unique ring. Research different styles, materials, and stones to find what resonates most with you or your partner's preferences.
• Evaluate the quality and authenticity of engagement rings by learning about gemstone grading systems, especially the "4Cs" for diamonds (Cut, Clarity, Color, and Carat).
• Seek guidance from our jewelry experts and loved ones who have experience navigating the process, helping you pick the ideal one that matches your skin tone, personality, taste, and design preferences.

The Bottom Line

What sets us apart is our focus on workmanship, trademark designs and storytelling. At Rogers & Hollands | Ashcroft & Oak, we focus on making top-notch jewelry with great care that is loved by you and your loved ones.

Each piece we create has its own special history, whether inspired by timeless designs or a product of our creative minds. With every piece we make, we put our best effort into ensuring that the ring speaks to you, matches your persona, and tells your story. It must always be a reminder of how special you are to us and to the people around you.

Whether you are looking for necklaces, bracelets, unique engagement rings, earrings, watches, or colored gemstones, we're here to help!